Difference between revisions of "Cancer Diet"

From Psiram
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
m
 
(23 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[image:Krebskiller.jpg|Unbelegte phantastische Behauptungen auf der ersten Seite der Bildzeitung<ref>Bildzeitung, erste Seite vom 28.1.2010</ref>|250px|thumb]]  
+
[[image:cancerdiet3.jpg|thumb]]
A '''cancer diet''' is a way of alimentation or diet intended to heal or cure a cancer disease in a causal way or to prolong survival time. A wider understanding of the term "cancer diet" includes also a diet intended to improve quality of life of cancer patients without affecting prognosis.  
+
[[image:Krebskiller.jpg|Phantastic claims without reference on front page of German Bild-Zeitung<ref>Bild-Zeitung, first page January 28, 2010</ref>|200px|thumb]]
 +
A '''cancer diet''' is a way of alimentation or diet intended to heal or cure a cancer disease in a causal way or to prolong survival time. A wider understanding of the term "cancer diet" also includes a diet intended to improve the quality of life of cancer patients without affecting prognosis.
  
So far, specific cancer diets are not accepted in scientific medicine, and are common in an alternative medicine environment. However, most cancer patients choose also concomitand alternative therapies in a complementary way to an effective therapy.
+
So far, specific cancer diets are not accepted in scientific medicine, but are common in an environment of alternative medicine. However, most cancer patients also choose concomitant alternative therapies to an effective therapy in a complementary way.
  
Specific cancer diets are nutritional recommendations going beyond generic recommendations and include usually unusual components, for instance the intake of herbal substances or the prohibition of a particular way of alimentation or particular substances. The recommandations found (in books or the internet) are commonly backed only by theoretical considerations. and usually lacking any scientific proof or literature.
+
Specific cancer diets are nutritional recommendations going beyond generic recommendations and usually include unusual components, for instance the consumption of herbal substances, or prohibit a particular way of alimentation or particular substances. The recommendations found (in books or the internet) as a rule are backed only by theoretical considerations and usually lack any scientific proof or literature.
  
In general, almost every cancer diet is claimed to be effective in a preventive way and at the same time also in a curative way. Cancer - prevention and cure are often confused or mixed. However, a common cancer patient is much les interested in prevention of a possible future (different) cancer disease, but seeks healing or relief of his present state. Most cancer patients are aware that a chemotherapy or radiation therapy may trigger a future cancer.
+
In general, almost every cancer diet is claimed to be effective in a preventive way and, at the same time, also in a curative way. Cancer prevention and cure are often confused or mixed. However, a common cancer patient is much less interested in prevention of a possible future (different) cancer disease, but seeks healing or relief of his present state. Most cancer patients are aware that chemotherapy or radiation therapy may trigger a future cancer.
  
==Common types of cancer diets==
+
==Common Cancer Diet Models==
Häufig anzutreffende Erklärungsmodelle sind:
+
Common explanations for cancer diets are:
*Eine angebliche "Entgiftung" oder [[Entschlackung]] des Organismus von meist nicht genau beschriebenen Giften oder ''Schlacken''.
 
*Stärkung der körpereigenen Abwehrkräfte / des Immunsystems
 
*Andere Ansätze hoffen die Krebszellen "auszuhungern" (siehe [[Breuß-Kur]]) oder selektiv zu vergiften, was einer bildhaften Vorstellung entspricht, die jeder wissenschaftlichen Grundlage entbehrt und Gefahren in sich birgt.
 
*Hypothesen auf der Basis der Warburg-Hypothese zum Energiestoffwechsel
 
  
==Bekannte Krebsdiäten==
+
*an alleged [[detoxification]] of usually not specified "toxins" or "waste"
[[image:CoyGong2.jpg|Boulevardpresse: Gong-Artikel zur [[Krebsdiät nach Coy]]<ref>Gong 4.9.2009</ref>|thumb]]
+
*strengthening of the immune system
*Anthroposophische Krebsdiät nach Renzenbrink. Eine Vollwertkost, jedoch ohne Nachtschattengewächse (Tomaten, Kartoffeln). Entwickelt von dem deutschen Arzt Udo Renzenbrink (1913-1994)
+
*famishing of cancer cells (see [[Breuß cure]]) or selective intoxication of cancer cells
*[[Breuß-Kur]]: Sechs Wochen lang ausschließlich Gemüsesäfte (Karotten, Sellerie, Kartoffeln, Rettich) und bestimmte Tees. Entwickelt von dem österreichischen Landwirt und Heilpraktiker Rudolf Breuß (1899-1990)
+
*recommendations in accordance with the [[Warburg effect]] of energy metabolism (examples: [[Budwig diet]] or [[Coy diet]])
*[[Gerson-Diät]]: [[Kaffee-Einlauf|Einläufe mit Kaffee]], Abführmittel, Leberextrakte, Iod, Vitamine, Pepsin. Wenig Eiweiß, Zucker, Salz.
 
*Trennkost nach [[Howard Hay]]: Eiweiße und Kohlenhydrate streng getrennt.
 
*[[Instinctotherapie]] nach [[Guy Claude Burger]]: Keinerlei gekochte oder gebratene Speisen, auch Fleisch und Fisch dürfen nur roh gegessen werden.
 
*Isopathische Milchsäurendiät oder Schutzkost nach [[Johannes Kuhl]]: Rechtsdrehende Milchsäure.
 
*Krebsdiät nach Ernst Leupold: Extrem kohlenhydratarme Kost, Infusionen mit Zucker und Insulin. Kein Obst außer Zitronen.
 
*Makrobiotische Kost nach Kushi-Ohsawa und Schülern (Makrobiotik): Vorwiegend Getreideprodukte, verstärkt grüne blanchierte Blätter und 100% Weglassung aller sogenannter "yinniger Nachrungsmittel".
 
*[[Krebsdiät nach Moerman|Krebsdiät nach Cornelius Moerman]]: Vollwertkost sowie Jod, Zitronensäure, Hefe, Weizen, Schwefel und Vitamine.
 
*[[Öl-Eiweißkost]] nach [[Johanna Budwig]]: Leinsamen- und Nussöl, Sauerkrautsaft, Gemüse- und Obstsäfte.
 
*Krebsdiät nach [[Catherine Kousmine]]: Getreide und Rohkost, kein Fleisch.
 
*[[3E-Programm nach Hirneise]]: Entwickelt von dem ehemaligen Krankenpfleger [[Lothar Hirneise]].
 
*Vollwertkost nach Maximilian Bircher-Benner: Wenig Fett, viel Gemüse und Getreide, Milchprodukte, Obst, Fisch statt Fleisch.
 
*[[Kelley-Gonzalez-Therapie]].
 
*[[10-Wege-Therapie nach Seeger]].
 
*[[Krebsdiät nach Coy]]
 
  
==Kritik==
+
==Known Cancer Diets==
Die einzelnen Empfehlungen widersprechen sich häufig und präventive Effekte werden häufig mit kurativen Effekten verwechselt.
+
[[image:MoermanDiet.jpg|left|thumb]]
 +
*[[Anthroposophy|anthroposophic]] cancer diet according to Renzenbrink. A "whole foods" alimentation, without food originating from solanaceae (tomatoes, potatoes). Developed by German physician Udo Renzenbrink (1913-1994)
 +
*[[Breuß cure]]: only vegetable juices (carrot, celery, potatoes, radishes) and particular teas for six weeks. Developed by Austrian farmer and "Heilpraktiker" (naturopath) Rudolf Breuß (1899-1990)
 +
*[[Gerson diet]]: [[Coffee enema|coffee enemas]], laxatives, liver-extracts, iodine, vitamins and pepsine. Some proteins, sugar, and salt.
 +
*[[Howard Hay diet]]: proteins and carbohydrates well separated.
 +
*[[Instinctotherapy]] according to [[Guy Claude Burger]]: no cooked or heated food, but raw meat and fish is permitted.
 +
*Isopathic lactic acid diet or protective diet according to [[Johannes Kuhl]]: optically (+) lactic acid.
 +
*Cancer diet according to Ernst Leupold: extreme carbohydrate-deficient diet, infusions with sugar and insuline. No fruit (except for lemons).
 +
*[[Macrobiotics|Macrobiotic diet according to Kushi-Ohsawa and his followers: mostly grains.
 +
*[[Moerman diet]] according to Cornelius Moerman: "whole food" and iodine, citric acid, yeast, wheat, sulfur, and vitamins.
 +
*[[Oil-protein diet]] according to [[Johanna Budwig]]: flax seed oils and nut oils, cabbage juice (Sauerkrautsaft), vegetable and fruit juices.
 +
*Cancer diet according to [[Catherine Kousmine]]: grains and raw food, no meat.
 +
*[[Hirneise 3E-program]]: developed by former nurse [[Lothar Hirneise]].
 +
*Whole Food diet according to Maximilian Bircher-Benner: Little fat, vegetables and grain in large quantities, milk products, fruit, fish instead of meat.
 +
*[[Kelley Gonzalez therapy]].
 +
*[[Seeger 10 way therapy]].
 +
*[[Coy diet]]
  
Für keine Krebs-Diätform wurde bisher nach den Maßstäben der evidenzbasierten Medizin die Wirksamkeit nachgewiesen. Im Gegenteil kann eine sehr einseitige Kost, etwa die [[Makrobiotik|Makrobiotische Kost]] in der höchsten Anwendungsstufe, bei Gesunden und Kranken zu Mangelerscheinungen führen.
+
==Criticism==
 +
These various cancer diets are very different from each other and contradictory. Alleged preventive effects are often mixed with a possible curative approach.
  
==Literatur==
+
No specific cancer diet has been accepted by evidence based medicine so far. To the contrary: a one-sided and limited diet (e.g. macrobiotics in its extreme form) may be harmful, cause nutritional deficits, and may increase weight loss.
 +
 
 +
{{OtherLang|ge=Krebsdiät|en=Cancer diet}}
 +
 
 +
==Literature==
 
#Kasper H, Bartram P, Scheppach W (1992) Tumorentstehung - hemmende und fördernde Effekte von Ernährungsfaktoren. In: Deutsche Gesellschaft für Ernährung (Hrsg) Ernährungsbericht 1992. Frankfurt: Eigenverlag, S. 251-286
 
#Kasper H, Bartram P, Scheppach W (1992) Tumorentstehung - hemmende und fördernde Effekte von Ernährungsfaktoren. In: Deutsche Gesellschaft für Ernährung (Hrsg) Ernährungsbericht 1992. Frankfurt: Eigenverlag, S. 251-286
 
#Dötsch R (1994) Die Bewertung von Außenseitermethoden (”Krebsdiäten”) in der Onkologie. Akt Ernähr-Med 19: 322
 
#Dötsch R (1994) Die Bewertung von Außenseitermethoden (”Krebsdiäten”) in der Onkologie. Akt Ernähr-Med 19: 322
Line 54: Line 58:
 
*http://www.geocities.com/~ollenschlaeger/krebsdiat.pdf
 
*http://www.geocities.com/~ollenschlaeger/krebsdiat.pdf
  
==references==
+
==References==
 
<references/>
 
<references/>
 +
------------------------
 +
*[http://www.psiram.com/ge/index.php?title=Krebsdi%C3%A4t same article in German]
  
[[category:cancer diet]]
+
[[category:Cancer Diet]]
[[category:pseudomedical therapy]]
+
[[category:Pseudomedical Therapy]]

Latest revision as of 16:33, 1 March 2013

Cancerdiet3.jpg
Phantastic claims without reference on front page of German Bild-Zeitung[1]

A cancer diet is a way of alimentation or diet intended to heal or cure a cancer disease in a causal way or to prolong survival time. A wider understanding of the term "cancer diet" also includes a diet intended to improve the quality of life of cancer patients without affecting prognosis.

So far, specific cancer diets are not accepted in scientific medicine, but are common in an environment of alternative medicine. However, most cancer patients also choose concomitant alternative therapies to an effective therapy in a complementary way.

Specific cancer diets are nutritional recommendations going beyond generic recommendations and usually include unusual components, for instance the consumption of herbal substances, or prohibit a particular way of alimentation or particular substances. The recommendations found (in books or the internet) as a rule are backed only by theoretical considerations and usually lack any scientific proof or literature.

In general, almost every cancer diet is claimed to be effective in a preventive way and, at the same time, also in a curative way. Cancer prevention and cure are often confused or mixed. However, a common cancer patient is much less interested in prevention of a possible future (different) cancer disease, but seeks healing or relief of his present state. Most cancer patients are aware that chemotherapy or radiation therapy may trigger a future cancer.

Common Cancer Diet Models

Common explanations for cancer diets are:

  • an alleged detoxification of usually not specified "toxins" or "waste"
  • strengthening of the immune system
  • famishing of cancer cells (see Breuß cure) or selective intoxication of cancer cells
  • recommendations in accordance with the Warburg effect of energy metabolism (examples: Budwig diet or Coy diet)

Known Cancer Diets

MoermanDiet.jpg
  • anthroposophic cancer diet according to Renzenbrink. A "whole foods" alimentation, without food originating from solanaceae (tomatoes, potatoes). Developed by German physician Udo Renzenbrink (1913-1994)
  • Breuß cure: only vegetable juices (carrot, celery, potatoes, radishes) and particular teas for six weeks. Developed by Austrian farmer and "Heilpraktiker" (naturopath) Rudolf Breuß (1899-1990)
  • Gerson diet: coffee enemas, laxatives, liver-extracts, iodine, vitamins and pepsine. Some proteins, sugar, and salt.
  • Howard Hay diet: proteins and carbohydrates well separated.
  • Instinctotherapy according to Guy Claude Burger: no cooked or heated food, but raw meat and fish is permitted.
  • Isopathic lactic acid diet or protective diet according to Johannes Kuhl: optically (+) lactic acid.
  • Cancer diet according to Ernst Leupold: extreme carbohydrate-deficient diet, infusions with sugar and insuline. No fruit (except for lemons).
  • [[Macrobiotics|Macrobiotic diet according to Kushi-Ohsawa and his followers: mostly grains.
  • Moerman diet according to Cornelius Moerman: "whole food" and iodine, citric acid, yeast, wheat, sulfur, and vitamins.
  • Oil-protein diet according to Johanna Budwig: flax seed oils and nut oils, cabbage juice (Sauerkrautsaft), vegetable and fruit juices.
  • Cancer diet according to Catherine Kousmine: grains and raw food, no meat.
  • Hirneise 3E-program: developed by former nurse Lothar Hirneise.
  • Whole Food diet according to Maximilian Bircher-Benner: Little fat, vegetables and grain in large quantities, milk products, fruit, fish instead of meat.
  • Kelley Gonzalez therapy.
  • Seeger 10 way therapy.
  • Coy diet

Criticism

These various cancer diets are very different from each other and contradictory. Alleged preventive effects are often mixed with a possible curative approach.

No specific cancer diet has been accepted by evidence based medicine so far. To the contrary: a one-sided and limited diet (e.g. macrobiotics in its extreme form) may be harmful, cause nutritional deficits, and may increase weight loss.

Versions of this article in other languages

Literature

  1. Kasper H, Bartram P, Scheppach W (1992) Tumorentstehung - hemmende und fördernde Effekte von Ernährungsfaktoren. In: Deutsche Gesellschaft für Ernährung (Hrsg) Ernährungsbericht 1992. Frankfurt: Eigenverlag, S. 251-286
  2. Dötsch R (1994) Die Bewertung von Außenseitermethoden (”Krebsdiäten”) in der Onkologie. Akt Ernähr-Med 19: 322
  3. Ollenschläger. Welchen Nutzen haben sogenannte "Krebsdiäten" ? Der informierte Arzt - Gazette Médicale 1996; 17: 213-220 [www.ollenschlaeger.net]
  4. Jungi WF (1986) Krebsdiäten. In: Jungi WF, Senn HJ (Hrsg) Krebs und Alternativmedizin. Aktuelle Onkologie, Bd. 32. München: Zuckschwerdt Verlag, S: 284-294
  5. Kasper H (1991) Tumordiät - Fakt oder Phantasie. In: Schauder P (Hrsg) Ernährung und Tumorerkrankungen. Basel: Karger, S. 440-453
  6. Halliwell B (1994) Free radicals, antioxidants and human disease: curiosity, cause, or consequence. Lancet 344: 721-724
  7. Bitsch R, Sinnhuber, Oberritter H, Großklaus R, Müller MJ, Wolfram G (1994) Alternative Diäten - Wunderdiäten? Akt Ernähr-Med 19: 195-211
  8. Birkhan B (1993) Unkonventionelle Konzepte in der Diätetik. In: Oepen I (Hrsg) Unkonventionelle medizinische Verfahren. Stuttgart: Gustav Fischer, S. 221-241
  9. Strube H (1995) Außenseiterdiäten. In: Biesalski HK et al (Hrsg) Ernährungsmedizin. Stuttgart: Thieme, S. 483-493
  10. Ollenschläger G, Thomas W, Konkol K, Diehl V, Roth E (1992) Nutritional behaviour and quality of life during oncological polychemotherapy: Results of a prospective study on the efficacy of oral nutrition

Weblinks

References

  1. Bild-Zeitung, first page January 28, 2010